lilianandmurdoch@googlemail.com wrote:


> "Alcoholism is not a disease," say Lilian and Murdoch.

This is hogwash. Science has firmly established the physiological
differences between alcoholics and non-alcoholics in brain chemistry and
the way alcohol is processed by the body. The genetic link has been well
documented also.

As far as accusing treatment centers of profiting from AA, it seems just
as reasonable to argue that YOU are attempting to profit from every
alcoholics desire to be able to continue drinking.

Is AA perfect? No. If you want to start a new worldwide organization, be
my guest.

I agree that certain people can develop a problem with excessive
drinking, and eventually return to "normal" drinking. I'm sure your book
might be of help to them. However, these people are not true alcoholics.

As it says in the AA big book, if you're not sure whether or not you're
an alcoholic, go ahead and try some controlled drinking. AA will still
be there when you find your answer.